You choose, we deliver
If you are interested in this story, you might be interested in others from The Journal Gazette. Go to www.journalgazette.net/newsletter and pick the subjects you care most about. We'll deliver your customized daily news report at 3 a.m. Fort Wayne time, right to your email.

Editorials

  • Path open to an Open Door ruling
    While the Indiana State Board of Education’s political battle with state Superintendent Glenda Ritz rages on, a Marion County judge has ruled the board’s legal battle also will continue.
  • A healing gesture
    Steve Shine’s job as Allen County GOP chairman is to get Republicans elected. The task is tougher in city races, where his party doesn’t enjoy the numbers advantage it holds throughout the county.
  • Path open to an Open Door ruling
     While the Indiana State Board of Education’s political battle with state Superintendent Glenda Ritz rages on, a Marion County judge has ruled the board’s legal battle also will conti ...
Advertisement
Study committees
In preparation for the 2015 session, the Indiana legislature has organized several legislative study committees to focus on key topics this summer. Among the subjects to be studied are:
•A statewide policy for recreational trails and maintenance;
•Risk of chronic wasting disease at high-fenced hunting preserves and deer farms;
•Juvenile justice;
•Digital privacy;
•Student discipline;
•Work sharing and unemployment benefits;
•Factors contributing to the shift of the local property tax burden;
•Various issues involving annexation;
•Gambling competition;
•Specialty group license plates; and
•Business personal property tax changes.
Times and places for the meetings have not yet been set. They will be available at the legislature’s website, iga.in.gov.
Editorial

Canned hunting among Indiana summer study issues

Zoeller
File

For more than a decade, Indiana has been struggling to resolve the issue of canned hunting – the practice of confining docile, farm-bred deer within a high-fenced “preserve” and charging visitors thousands of dollars to shoot them.

During this year's session, the Indiana Senate fell just short of approving a measure that would have imposed a few regulations on the state's four canned-hunting sites but would have legitimized them and perhaps encouraged the opening of others.

Those who backed the bill seemed to be unduly concerned about the economic benefits that flow from this inherently unsporting practice and oddly dismissive of the dangers posed to wild deer herds by the domesticated deer imported from other states.

Imported deer could bring chronic wasting disease, an always-fatal deer malady that could devastate the legitimate hunting industry in Indiana as it has in other states. Some balance may be restored to the discussion this summer. At the request of Senate President Pro Tem David Long, R-Fort Wayne, and Rep. Sean Eberhart, R-Shelbyville, the chairman of the House Natural Resources Committee, the legislature has authorized a summer study committee to look carefully at the CWD issue as it relates to the four canned-hunting operations and the nearly 400 deer farms in the state.

Long has spoken caustically about canned hunting in the past and voted against passage of this year's measure. A powerful series about the issue in The Indianapolis Star a few weeks ago galvanized concern.

Last week, the office of Attorney General Greg Zoeller also weighed in, filing a brief urging the Indiana Court of Appeals to recognize that responsibility for regulating the high-fenced hunting operations rightly belongs to the state's Department of Natural Resources.

The DNR tried to shut down canned hunting in 2005, but that effort remained in limbo until last year, when a judge in Harrison County ruled against the DNR, though an Owen County judge previously had ruled in favor of the agency.

In an effort to resolve the matter, the attorney general's appeal of the Harrison County ruling argues that denying DNR oversight on a wildlife-related issue creates “a regulation-free environment where individuals can hunt without a license, out of season, with weapons not typically used for hunting and with blatant disregard for Indiana's safety and ethical hunting standards.”

Preserve operators have argued that their deer are exempt from DNR oversight because they really should be classified as livestock. But if that's the case, the attorney general's office argued, state law would prevent them from being hunted.

It's encouraging to see the legislature giving the issue more thought, and Zoeller is to be commended for taking the issue on in the courts. One way or another, the reckless trafficking in and unethical slaughter of deer have to be brought under control.

Advertisement