You choose, we deliver
If you are interested in this story, you might be interested in others from The Journal Gazette. Go to www.journalgazette.net/newsletter and pick the subjects you care most about. We'll deliver your customized daily news report at 3 a.m. Fort Wayne time, right to your email.

U.S.

  • Full holiday menu for Obamas; 6 pies for dessert
    WASHINGTON – President Barack Obama spent a quiet Thanksgiving at the White House where the belly-stuffing menu featured all the holiday’s basics.
  • Immigrants Social Security eligible in Obama plan
    WASHINGTON (AP) — Many immigrants in the United States illegally who apply for work permits under President Barack Obama's new executive actions would be eligible for Social Security and Medicare benefits upon reaching retirement age,
  • Video: Cleveland officer shot boy within seconds
    CLEVELAND (AP) — The police officer who fatally shot a 12-year-old boy carrying a pellet gun fired within 1½ to 2 seconds of pulling up in his cruiser, police said Wednesday. During those few moments, he ordered the youngster three times to
Advertisement
Also
Obama calls death penalty problematic
WASHINGTON – President Barack Obama on Friday called the botched execution of an Oklahoma inmate “deeply troubling” and announced that he’s going to ask the attorney general to analyze problems surrounding the application of the death penalty in the United States.
Obama’s first public comments on the case came during a White House news conference with visiting German Chancellor Angela Merkel, when he was asked about international condemnation of U.S. application of the death penalty in light of Clayton Lockett’s case.
He said the death penalty’s application in the United States is problematic, with evidence of racial bias and eventual exoneration of some death row inmates. “And this situation in Oklahoma, I think, just highlights some of the significant problems there,” he said.
The president said he’ll be asking Attorney General Eric Holder and others “to get me an analysis of what steps have been taken, not just in this particular instance, but more broadly in this area.” The White House and Justice Department declined to comment further on what that might cover.
Associated Press
Dr. Jonathan Weisbuch says doctors shouldn’t participate in lethal injections on ethical grounds.

Botched execution drives debate on role of doctors

– A botched lethal injection in Oklahoma this week has renewed a debate on whether doctors should be banned from executions – or required to participate to make the process more humane.

Some of the nation’s 32 death penalty states mandate doctor participation – including Oklahoma – but critics say what happened there proves a doctor’s presence can’t guarantee the process will go smoothly.

“Physicians have an ethical and moral responsibility to remain as far from the execution chamber as possible,” said Dr. Jonathan Weisbuch of Phoenix, a death penalty opponent. He calls what happened in Oklahoma torture.

“How dare they experiment on a living human being,” Weisbuch said.

In Oklahoma on Tuesday, the execution team struggled to find a suitable vein for injecting the lethal drugs and a vein collapse prevented the drugs from working properly.

Clayton Lockett, a convicted murderer, writhed before the execution was called off. He died later of apparent heart attack.

According to witnesses and a letter from the state’s prisons chief, a physician checked the IV line, checked to see whether Lockett was unconscious and reported that not enough drugs had been given to kill him – all violations of the American Medical Association’s ethics policy.

The AMA says it’s unethical for doctors to be involved except in a peripheral way. That’s one reason the number and identities of physicians who do participate are shrouded in secrecy.

Whether U.S. physicians strongly adhere to their oath to do no harm, only about 20 percent of them are AMA members.

Dr. Ardis Dee Hoven, the AMA’s president, issued a statement Friday regarding Lockett’s execution.

“No matter how one feels about capital punishment, it is disquieting for physicians to act as agents of the state in the assisting, supervising or contributing to a legally authorized execution,” Hoven said.

Weisbuch says the Oklahoma case underscores why an execution moratorium is needed. He plans to ask the AMA to lobby for a ban at the group’s policymaking meeting next month in Chicago. Similar attempts have failed.

Richard Dieter, executive director of the Death Penalty Information Center, an advocacy group critical of how capital punishment is usually carried out, said doctors’ participation in executions often pits the medical profession against the judicial system.

“Lawsuits say this is a medical procedure being done by guards – it could go wrong,” Dieter said. “Courts want assurances” that condemned inmates won’t suffer, he said.

Dieter said states’ execution protocols often don’t specify what role doctors play, and they’re often updated, so it’s difficult to quantify the number of doctors involved. Dieter said his organization doesn’t keep tabs.

Here are some examples of current execution rules:

•Texas says unspecified members of “the drug team” inject the drugs, and a physician enters the death chamber when the execution is over, “to examine the offender, pronounce the offender’s death, and designate the official time of death.”

•North Carolina says a doctor will monitor the condemned inmate “and immediately notify the warden of any signs of undue pain or suffering.”

•Kentucky’s mandate says, “No physician shall be involved in the conduct of an execution except to certify cause of death provided that the condemned is declared dead by another person.”

Dr. Neil Farber, a University of California-San Diego internist and educator, said surveys he did more than a decade ago found that almost 20 percent of doctors would be willing to perform lethal injections.

Farber said it’s likely Lockett’s execution will change some minds.

“I sure hope so,” he said. “Whether a physician supports or is opposed to the death penalty, I think it is something society needs to address.”

Advertisement