You choose, we deliver
If you are interested in this story, you might be interested in others from The Journal Gazette. Go to www.journalgazette.net/newsletter and pick the subjects you care most about. We'll deliver your customized daily news report at 3 a.m. Fort Wayne time, right to your email.

Schools

  • Discovering science in books
    Campers at Science Central got the chance to concoct wizardlike, Harry Potter-style potions – a required course at the fictional Hogwarts School, but until last week, not available in the Fort W ...
  • Ed board member picks up mantle
    Cari Whicker is a teacher 24 hours a day, even on a recent 3,200-mile summer vacation out West with her family. “We don’t go anywhere without a packet of stuff so we can learn,” she said.
  • Ivy Tech opens path to better life for refugees
    A mother and teenage daughter from Haiti. Cousins from the Democratic Republic of the Congo. An eager, young woman from Burma.
Advertisement

Educator evaluations called into question

As colleges and universities celebrate the good marks their graduates received, Derek Redelman said the data might not accurately reflect how educators are performing. Redelman is vice president for Education and Workforce Policy at the Indiana Chamber of Commerce.

Like any profession, it’s expected that there would be educators at both ends of the spectrum, he said.

“Most districts did have the biggest number in the effective category, and that’s a reasonable expectation. But it’s not reasonable for large districts to suggest they have no teachers who are ineffective or who need improvement,” Redelman said.

Some members of the Indiana State Board of Education, including Superintendent of Public Instruction Glenda Ritz, said the results are too good to be true.

Teachers in the higher two tiers are eligible for pay increases, and some board members said tying the evaluations to pay might have discouraged honest answers.

Justin Ohlemiller, state director of the education reform group Stand for Children, asked how the majority of teachers rated effective or highly effective if 1 in 4 students didn’t pass the standardized tests.

“Given that 1 in 4 Hoosier children are not passing the state ISTEP assessment, how is it that 97 percent of those teachers who were rated have been classified in the top two categories of effectiveness? Today’s data simply does not correlate with the student results we’re seeing in the classroom,” Ohlemiller said in a statement.

Despite the flaws, Redelman said that requiring school districts to complete annual evaluations of educators is a step in the right direction.

“Having so many schools now doing annual evaluations is a very good start. Some took that evaluation process seriously and identified a significant number of teachers needing improvement,” Rendelman said. “ … There’s nothing more important in the school than the teachers.”

jcrothers@jg.net

Advertisement