INDIANAPOLIS – Three federal lawsuits were filed Friday against Indiana’s same-sex marriage ban, boosting the number of legal challenges to the ban’s constitutionality to at least five.
The American Civil Liberties Union of Indiana filed a lawsuit Friday on behalf of five gay couples and three other plaintiffs in federal court in Indianapolis.
That suit contends that Indiana’s gay marriage ban violates the U.S. Constitution’s Equal Protection and Due Process clauses of the 14th Amendment and asks a judge to declare it unconstitutional.
Ken Falk, chief legal counsel for the ACLU of Indiana, said he expects the growing number of federal lawsuits will be consolidated into a single challenge against the state’s marriage law.
He said the ACLU’s challenge citing the 14th Amendment involves complicated legal notions that when boiled down stand for two things – fairness and equality.
And there is nothing more unfair and there’s nothing more unequal in Indiana today than the fact that we deny loving couples the right to marry solely because of their sexual preference, he said at a news conference.
Indiana Attorney General Greg Zoeller has said his office will defend the state’s marriage laws.
The ACLU’s suit contends Indiana’s gay marriage ban discriminates against the 13 plaintiffs, including two children whose parents are among the plaintiffs.
It also says Indiana denies legal protections, tax advantages and other benefits to the couples, three of whom were married in states that allow same-sex marriage.
One of the plaintiffs is Midori Fujii, a Hamilton County resident who married her longtime partner, Kris Brittain, in California in 2008, three years before Brittain died of ovarian cancer.
Because Indiana doesn’t recognize same-sex marriages that are legal in other states Fujii had to pay more than $300,000 in Indiana inheritance tax after Brittain’s death.
If Indiana recognized same-sex marriages, Fujii – like any Indiana widow – would have had to pay no inheritance tax, said her attorney, Sean Lemieux.
When you’ve spent your lives together, saving, building assets, protecting yourself, to have that then go into taxes because your marriage is disrespected is not only emotionally insulting but financially harmful, he said.
Another suit was filed Friday by four lesbian couples who were married in states that allow same-sex marriages.
Three of those couples have spouses who are police officers, while the spouse of the fourth couple is a retired firefighter.
A third federal lawsuit was filed Friday on behalf of a lesbian couple from Indiana who were married in Iowa and another woman who was also married in that state to her same-sex partner, but is now in the midst of a divorce.