You choose, we deliver
If you are interested in this story, you might be interested in others from The Journal Gazette. Go to www.journalgazette.net/newsletter and pick the subjects you care most about. We'll deliver your customized daily news report at 3 a.m. Fort Wayne time, right to your email.

Editorial columns

  • Even great powers cowed by deaths of innocents
    Modern low-intensity conflicts are won and lost on their ragged edges. Nations act as though the careful plans of their militaries and intelligence operations can harness the chaos of combat and guide it to advance their interests.
  • Merkel the model for female leadership
    Would women be better than men at running the world? There’s a case to be made on the example of Angela Merkel, currently the longest-serving – and most popular – leader of a Group of Seven country.
  • Making your marketing, socially
    When the Fort Wayne TinCaps printed the names of their then-6,000 Twitter followers on a special jersey in 2013, they got national praise. ESPN’s official Twitter account said:
Advertisement
Associated Press
Bottled water went quickly in areas of West Virginia affected by last week’s chemical spill.

W. Virginia spill leaves a thirst for federal regs

Why did West Virginia officials have to order 300,000 people to give up tap water in and around Charleston, the state capital, for days?

In part because they didn’t know the health risks associated with 4-methylcyclohexane methanol, the chemical that spilled from riverside storage tanks and into the water supply last week. And they still don’t, according to an Environmental Defense Fund analysis, because information on its risks is amazingly scant.

Americans see pictures of brown, pollution-packed air in Beijing or red, chemical-saturated rivers in Hungary and may assume that the time of such spectacular environmental dangers has passed in the United States. That’s in large part because of regulations from the last century that protect the air and water against the riskiest sorts of pollution. But those laws sometimes fail because they aren’t perfect or because they aren’t perfectly applied.

The West Virginia water emergency reflects both. According to the state’s environmental chief, the storage plant dates to 1938, a time before modern environmental regulation. A downstream water treatment plant was old, too. Some rudimentary federal reporting and permitting rules covered the chemical storage site. Yet federal and state oversight were inadequate. The site was last inspected in 1991.

In fact, a lot of environmental protection depends on state officials. Federal requirements, meanwhile, are spotty. Some quantities of some chemicals trigger notification requirements. But for many chemicals in regular use, federal law does not require safety data.

That’s because the governing law, passed in 1976, presumed that chemicals in use at the time were safe. Bizarrely, to order testing on chemicals grandfathered in, the Environmental Protection Agency must offer evidence that they aren’t safe in an onerous bureaucratic process. A bipartisan chemical safety reform bill on the table in Congress would improve matters, but it hasn’t yet moved. It should.

A combination of state regulators using a bit of sense – like asking about an old tank farm next to a drinking water facility – and better federal law – like requiring more information on chemical safety – might have prevented or limited the damage and dislocation the people of Charleston have seen.

Advertisement