You choose, we deliver
If you are interested in this story, you might be interested in others from The Journal Gazette. Go to and pick the subjects you care most about. We'll deliver your customized daily news report at 3 a.m. Fort Wayne time, right to your email.


At a glance
Some details about the bank merger include:
•Tower Bank’s sale price was originally estimated at $107.7 million. Because it involves stock, the final price won’t be known until the closing.
•Tower has almost $681 million in total assets and seven branches.
•Old National has $9.6 billion in assets and 176 branches.
•Tower Bank branches are scheduled to be renamed Old National between April 1 and June 30.
•Tower’s six existing Fort Wayne branches and one Warsaw branch will all remain open.

Consolidation brings staff shake-up to Tower Bank


When Old National Bancorp announced plans to acquire Tower Bank, officials stressed that Tower customers would continue to see the same faces across the desk after the deal closes early next year.

That might have been the Evansville-based bank’s goal, but the September announcement has triggered a significant staff shake-up.

Five commercial lenders – from a staff of 12 – have resigned from Fort Wayne-based Tower. Their last official day was Thursday.

And Mike Cahill, Tower’s president and CEO, plans to leave in mid-May, after the banks’ computer systems are fully integrated. The acquisition is expected to close in mid-February.

Cahill said one reason he plans to leave is it wouldn’t seem right to keep his job when “a lot” of Tower workers will lose theirs in the consolidation. Cahill declined to specify the number of jobs expected to be eliminated, saying it’s not his place to release the information.

But, he said, all Tower employees have been notified. Those losing jobs will be allowed to stay on until May 1, giving them time to find new positions, Cahill said.

Bob Jones, Old National’s president and CEO, on Thursday said in an email that the final number hasn’t been decided. From the beginning, however, Old National officials have acknowledged that some Tower jobs would be lost behind the scenes, where payments are processed.

Tower employed 165 at the time of the acquisition announcement. Bank officials prefer to describe the estimated $107.7 million deal as a partnership because each bank brings strengths to the table.

Old National has well-developed agriculture lending and insurance businesses, which open new revenue opportunities in the Fort Wayne market. Also, its larger asset base allows the bank to make bigger loans than Tower has been able to make.

In return, Tower offers a thriving health savings accounts business and local relationships.

Those local relationships are threatened, however, now that five commercial lenders have left. Cahill said only one of the five had signed a one-year nonsolicit agreement that forbids him to call on former business clients for the next 12 months. The other four have no such restriction.

The lenders are staying local, going to work for a competing bank that’s not currently in the Fort Wayne market but plans to open here. Cahill declined to say which one but described it as “a decent-sized bank.” He expects a public announcement by that bank any time.

Jim Marcuccilli, STAR Bank’s president and CEO, said this kind of exodus often happens in the wake of an acquisition.

Banks that have been eying a market see an opportunity to ramp up quickly by raiding the disappearing bank’s lending team, he said. Bankers cultivate business by making contacts and building relationships.

Even so, Marcuccilli doubts Tower … or, ultimately, Old National … will lose existing loans as a result.

“People don’t just up and move accounts unless banks give them a good reason to,” he said. “I don’t think people will just up and make a decision (to change banks) because people switch jobs.”

Cahill expressed confidence that Tower’s loan portfolio will remain largely unaffected. Most business borrowers meet with numerous bank officials to address various financial needs, he said.

“If you lose a client because you lose the relationship manager, you really didn’t have a deep relationship with that client,” he said.

The outgoing CEO put a positive spin on the news. The five departures create space for three Tower employees to continue in commercial lending. They were slated to be transferred to different positions as part of the restructuring, he said.

Cahill described the five loan officers’ departure as very cordial and said he met three of them for a drink the week before Christmas.

“They saw this opportunity. They thought it was better for themselves,” he said. “Since change was coming, they chose the change they wanted.”

The coming change, of course, was the move under the Old National umbrella.

Old National has been aggressively adding to its statewide presence, acquiring banks based in Bloomington, Columbus and Evansville, among other cities. Since 2007, the company has acquired 175 branches, not including Tower’s seven.

Cahill brushed aside any notion that the lenders defected from Tower.

“I don’t think it’s a blow to Tower Bank,” he said. “They never would have left if Tower Bank hadn’t been sold.”

As for Cahill, Tower’s CEO was offered the regional president position.

“I don’t know Fort Wayne, and Fort Wayne doesn’t know me. But they know Mike Cahill, and they trust Mike Cahill,” Jones said in September.

But, in the end, Cahill decided “it just wasn’t me.”

Wendell Bontrager, Tower’s executive vice president and chief lending officer, will become Fort Wayne region president after the sale closes in February.

Cahill will transition to being the bank’s consultant, with a contract until mid-May.Cahill wasn’t ready to go from being the boss to having three layers of management above him. The 53-year-old has been in executive leadership positions since he was 27.

“And I’ve kind of liked that,” Cahill said.

The CEO is now updating his résumé.