WASHINGTON – The labor market is healing faster for immigrants than for U.S.-born workers as the growing economy favors those at the low and high ends of the pay scale.
Joblessness among those born outside the United States averaged 8.1 percent in 2012, down from 9.7 percent three years earlier, according to Labor Department data released to Bloomberg. In the same period, the rate among those born in the country fell to 8.1 percent from 9.2 percent.
Working immigrants, who are more likely than native-born Americans to either lack a high school diploma or to hold an advanced degree, have gained from a decades-long divergence in the labor market that has swelled demand for jobs paying above- and below-average wages. Amid this dynamic, the battle over comprehensive changes in immigration law is coming to the forefront in Congress.
Foreign-born workers increase efficiency in the economy, and by increasing efficiency, they eliminate bottlenecks, said Pia Orrenius, a senior economist at the Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas who has studied immigration. Their availability lowers overall unemployment and increases economic growth.
From 2009 through 2012, the number of immigrants employed in the U.S. rose 6.5 percent to 23 million, compared with a 1 percent gain to 119.5 million for those born in the U.S., Labor Department data show.
The data from the U.S. Labor Department also showed immigrants experienced job growth in 13 of 14 occupational categories tracked, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. U.S-born workers saw growth in nine.
Underlying those figures, immigrants’ gains during the past three years were concentrated in low- and high-paying categories that range from health care to management. Only in manufacturing did those born in the U.S. see bigger gains than their foreign counterparts.
The increases mirror a pattern that has developed in the labor market independent of birth status: Middle-income workers are losing out as low-wage jobs, such as landscaping and food preparation, and high-wage positions, such as dentistry and engineering, show outsized increases. Middle-wage jobs include work in office administration and factory production.
Economists including Daron Acemoglu and David Autor, both at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, have attributed this job polarization to the loss of positions that require repetitive tasks and can be replaced by technology.
The skillsets immigrants bring to the country help them fit into the available work opportunities. About 24 percent of employed foreigners over the age of 25 did not have a high school diploma in 2012, compared with 4.6 percent of American-born workers, according to the Labor Department. At the other extreme, 14.1 percent of working immigrants held an advanced degree, higher than the 13.5 percent of U.S.-born employees.
Immigrants basically go to industries that are growing and help them grow faster, Alex Nowrasteh, an immigration policy analyst at the Cato Institute in Washington, said in an interview. They grease the wheels of the labor market and the economy by moving specifically to areas where there is demand for a particular set of skills at a particular place and time.
There are, of course, experts who argue otherwise. Michael Teitelbaum, vice chairman of the U.S. Commission on Immigration Reform from 1991 to 1997 and now a fellow at Harvard University Law School, said in Feb. 5 testimony before Congress that an influx of less-skilled workers is detrimental.
His commission, charged by Congress with investigating how immigration affects the labor market, found that guest workers in areas such as agriculture are vulnerable to exploitation and their presence depresses wages and offers employers little incentive to improve working conditions. At the same time, his commission found that allowing the high skilled into the country contributes to global competitiveness.
Lawmakers in Washington are debating whether to tap this resource as the foreign born, particularly Hispanics, make up a bigger share of the electorate. Four Democratic and four Republican senators last month released a framework for the most comprehensive changes to immigration law in almost three decades.
Their proposal, yet to be drafted into legislation, calls for a path to citizenship for the nation’s 11 million undocumented immigrants, tougher border security and stronger prohibitions against racial profiling. It also seeks ways to more efficiently attract and retain immigrants who hold advanced degrees, especially in science, technology, engineering and math.
President Obama has called for a bill to be prepared in the next few months.
Our economy is stronger when we harness the talents and ingenuity of striving, hopeful immigrants, Obama said during his State of the Union address on Feb. 12. Right now, leaders from the business, labor, law enforcement, faith communities, they all agree that the time has come to pass comprehensive immigration reform.
Carola van Eck is among the beneficiaries of rising demand for high-skilled workers. She came to the U.S. in 2008 to work on her doctorate through a joint venture with the University of Amsterdam and the University of Pittsburgh. Though the 28-year-old said she intended to return home to the Netherlands, the draw of a job as a resident in Orthopedic Surgery at the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center prompted her to stay.
I really like the work ethic in the U.S., van Eck said. In my country, you’re always told to not be better than the boss. Here, you get rewarded for your accomplishments, which motivates you to work harder.
Miner Dedios typifies those on the other end of the income scale, where immigrants are finding their footing as the world’s largest economy improves.
Dedios, 64, moved to the U.S. in 2010 from the Philippines, intending to work as a firefighter, a middle-wage career. Unable to land a job in rescue work, he now sorts donations for Goodwill Industries International Inc. in Seattle.
Sometimes, native-born people are not interested in certain jobs at the current wage levels, said Audrey Singer, a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution in Washington who tracks international migration and policy. Immigrants fill in some of the gaps.
The foreign-born’s job prospects may continue to brighten. Immigrants make up a larger share of the most rapidly growing occupations, Singer found in research released last year. Among the 15 fields projected by the Labor Department to grow the most from 2010 to 2020, seven had a share of immigrants that was higher than immigrants’ total share of the labor force.
Lawmakers should keep such developments in mind when setting policy, she said.
What we haven’t really achieved in our system after decades of thinking about this is how to adjust the admissions policy to better suit our economic needs in something closer to real time, she said. That is going to be part of the discussion in the next couple of months. Do we make changes based on some market demand, and how do we measure that? Do we set out knowing what we want and then adjust our policies?