You choose, we deliver
If you are interested in this story, you might be interested in others from The Journal Gazette. Go to www.journalgazette.net/newsletter and pick the subjects you care most about. We'll deliver your customized daily news report at 3 a.m. Fort Wayne time, right to your email.

Ben Smith

Advertisement

Do classy thing: Leave IHSAA tourney alone

I wouldn’t know Sen. Jean Leising, R-Oldenburg, if she elbowed me in the face going after a rebound. But I do know she doesn’t recognize a dead horse when she sees one.

This upon the news that she’s sponsoring legislation – again! – to forbid school corporations from playing in the IHSAA if the IHSAA persists with class basketball.

Good grief. Can we not let this thing die, people?

I bow to no one in my conviction that class hoops killed high school basketball, or at least that March phenomenon we used to call Hoosier Hysteria, in the state of Indiana. The game’s hold on the psyche of an entire state died the instant the first ball was tossed up at the first class sectional game, and that’s simply the home truth of things.

But it’s been 14 years now, nearly long enough for an entire generation of Indiana kids to have grown up knowing nothing but class hoops. Dozens of communities around the state now have “Home of the Whatever Year Class 1A/2A/3A State Champions” signs on the outskirts of town. Whatever you think of what class hoops has done to the hold basketball has on this state in general, it’s been an unqualified success for those individual communities whose kids would never have experienced a state championship without it.

And this is me talking. This is the guy who saw the glory days 25 or 30 years ago, when I had the great good fortune to work in the best high school hoops town in America – Anderson – and spent my Friday nights trying to hear myself think in front of 8,000 people in the Wigwam.

Nothing like that will ever happen again in this state. Even if you go back and do it over 14 years later.

The fact is, this isn’t the world it was then, and it’s never going to be again. There’s too much else to do now on winter Friday nights, too many other entertainment options. Big Monday and Terrific Tuesday and Wonderful Wednesday on ESPN have forever muted Fantastic Friday, especially in the larger communities.

We can still mourn for what’s been lost, of course. The flip side of all those communities with their state champions signs on the edge of town is that what used to matter to the state as a whole matters only to those individual communities now. What used to be a communal experience – you pulled for your school in the sectional against all your local rivals, then pulled for “your” representative as it moved on to the regional and semistate – is now contained within the four walls of your own school.

That’s why it isn’t Hoosier Hysteria anymore. It’s only Garrett Hysteria or Warsaw Hysteria or Ossian Hysteria.

Which is all that matters, if you live in those places. It’s only the conceit of those of us who aren’t involved that single-class hoops was better because, even though you got beat 95-30 in the first game of the sectional, you got to be part of the grand pageant.

If I’m a kid on the losing end of that, my response would be this: “Whoop-de-doo. Give me a realistic shot at a 1A state title any day – and if a year later some geezer in Fort Wayne can’t remember who won the 1A title, what do I care? I’ll remember.”

And that’s the point the Lege should keep in mind before sticking its nose where it doesn’t belong. If it must, though, at least do the democratic thing: Put it to a vote.

Poll the kids, and then – unlike the IHSAA in 1997 – abide by the results. Let the kids decide what tournament they want to play in. In the end, after all, it’s their tournament.

No geezers need apply.

Ben Smith has been covering sports in Fort Wayne since 1986. His columns appear four times a week. He can be reached by email at bensmith@jg.net; phone, 461-8736; or fax 461-8648.